Tax Implications of Choosing Employees or Contractors

Learn the tax implications of choosing between employees and contractors, including who handles payroll taxes, benefits, and worker classification.

When you hire for your business, one of the first decisions you'll face is whether to bring someone on as an employee or as an independent contractor. The choice carries real tax consequences that affect your bottom line. This guide walks through what each path means for your taxes.

Employee vs. Contractor: The Basic Difference

The label you give a worker decides who handles the taxes. With an employee, you withhold and remit payroll taxes on their behalf. With a contractor, the worker is running their own business and handles their own taxes. Getting the classification right matters, because the IRS and state agencies treat misclassification as a serious problem.

Who Faces This Decision

Most businesses run into this question when they're growing, taking on more work than the current team can handle, or filling a specific skill gap. The goal is the same either way: find the right person. The difference is whether you do it through a full-time hire or by contracting the work out.

How Rules Vary by State

Worker classification isn't governed by federal law alone. Each state can set its own criteria. Some states track the IRS guidelines closely, while others add their own tests, California's ABC test being the strictest example. Check the rules where your worker is based before you settle on a classification.

Example Scenarios

Scenario 1: Hiring an Employee

If you choose to hire an employee, you'll be responsible for withholding income taxes, Social Security, and Medicare taxes from their wages. Additionally, you may need to contribute to unemployment insurance and workers' compensation. Employees are entitled to certain benefits, such as health insurance and retirement plans.

Scenario 2: Engaging an Independent Contractor

When engaging an independent contractor, you generally don't withhold taxes from their payments. Independent contractors are responsible for paying their own taxes, including self-employment tax. They have more flexibility in how they work and are not entitled to employee benefits.

Bottom Line

The tax side of this decision comes down to who carries the payroll burden and what benefits you're on the hook for. Weigh the cost of withholding, contributions, and benefits against the flexibility of contracting, then classify the worker honestly based on how the work actually gets done.

If you need to draft an employment contract or an independent contractor agreement, Contractable can help. Our AI-powered contract generator builds legally sound contracts tailored to your situation. Visit Contractable.ai to learn more.